Failed Hair Transplant Repair – Surgical Plan

Dr Bertram – Documented Outcomes in Complex Repair & Restore.

What Is Considered a Failed Hair Transplant ?

Last Updated: 6 Nov 2025

A hair transplant is a meticulous surgical procedure that depends on careful planning, surgical skill, and proper aftercare. When one or more of these elements are lacking, the outcome may be unsatisfactory or even harmful.

Over the years we have performed many repair cases. Repairing other doctors’ work is a difficult but challenging job which demands a lot of skill and experience. Unfortunately some cases were beyond repair, and we feel sorry that we cannot help everyone.

Below are key indicators and causes of a failed hair transplant:

Content-index

1. Poor Graft Survival

  • Definition: Less than 70% of the transplanted grafts grow permanently.

  • Causes:

    • Graft dehydration during surgery

    • Excessive trauma or transection of follicles

    • Poor storage (temperature, solutions)

    • Improper handling during implantation

    • Smoking or vascular compromise in the scalp

    • Inadequate post-op care or infection

2. Unnatural Hairline Design

  • Definition: Hairline appears too straight, low, or doll-like.

  • Causes:

    • Designed by non-medical staff without understanding facial harmony

    • Ignoring age-appropriate placement

    • Overuse of multi-hair grafts in frontal zone

    • Failure to follow natural hair flow

3. Visible Scarring

  • Definition: Obvious linear or punctate scarring in donor or recipient areas.

  • Causes:

    • Poor surgical closure in FUT

    • Overharvesting in FUE

    • Use of large punches or tools

    • Infection or delayed wound healing

4. Shock Loss Without Regrowth

  • Definition: Existing native hairs fall out post-surgery and do not regrow.

  • Causes:

    • Preexisting miniaturization not addressed

    • Aggressive graft placement damaging surrounding follicles

    • No pre-op medical stabilization with minoxidil or finasteride

5. Poor Density

  • Definition: Sparse or uneven coverage, with visible scalp despite transplant.

  • Causes:

    • Inadequate number of grafts used

    • Uneven distribution or poor angulation

    • Underestimation of hair loss progression

    • Overly conservative design

6. Donor Area Depletion

  • Definition: Overharvested donor zone with visible thinning or patchiness.

  • Causes:

    • Extracting too many grafts in one session

    • Ignoring donor density limitations

    • No long-term planning

7. Infection or Necrosis

  • Definition: Skin damage, pus, or blackened graft sites indicating tissue death.

  • Causes:

    • Unsterile environment

    • Inadequate post-op care or hygiene

    • Use of unqualified technicians

    • Overly tight packing of grafts

8. Misdiagnosis and Wrong Candidates

  • Definition: Patients undergo transplant despite not being suitable.

  • Causes:

    • Diffuse unpatterned alopecia mistaken for male pattern baldness

    • Active autoimmune alopecia (e.g., LPP, alopecia areata) not identified

    • Hair loss not yet stabilized

What Cases Are Suitable For Repair ?

Here’s a classification of the eight major causes of failed hair transplants into three categories — suitable, conditionally suitable, and unsuitable — for repair via hair transplant surgery :

CategoryExamples Repair Feasibility
✅ Suitable Unnatural hairline, poor density, scarring High success rate
⚠️ Conditionally Suitable Shock loss, donor depletion, poor survival Careful selection needed
❌ Unsuitable Typically not recommended Dr. Orentreich (USA) performed the first hair transplant for hair loss in men.

Group 1 - Suitable for Repair by Hair Transplant

These conditions can typically be corrected with careful planning and skilled surgery:

1. Unnatural Hairline Design
  • Can be redesigned using finer grafts and better angulation.

  • Old grafts may be removed or redistributed (e.g. graft excision or laser hair removal if needed).

2. Poor Density
  • A second session can add more grafts to fill gaps.

  • Requires good remaining donor supply.

3. Visible Scarring
  • Scars from FUT or FUE can be camouflaged using grafts (especially scalp micropigmentation or FUE into scar).

  • Success depends on local blood supply and scar type (atrophic > hypertrophic > keloid).

Group 2 - Conditionally Suitable for Repair

These cases need careful assessment and selective patient acceptance:

4. Poor Graft Survival
  • A second transplant may help if the donor area is still intact and causes have been corrected (e.g., poor technique, storage, or handling in the first surgery).

5. Shock Loss Without Regrowth
  • If the surrounding native hair was already miniaturized and didn’t return, a transplant may replace what’s lost.

  • Patients must be stabilized medically first (finasteride, minoxidil, PRP, etc.).

6. Donor Area Depletion
  • Repair is limited.

  • May require scalp micropigmentation, body-to-scalp hair transplant, or a reduced aesthetic target (e.g., limited coverage).

Group 3 - Not Suitable for Repair

These cases are generally poor candidates unless underlying issues are corrected or ruled out:

7. Infection or Necrosis
  • If tissue damage is extensive, transplant may not be possible.

  • Requires scar remodeling and vascular assessment before any repair.

8. Misdiagnosis and Wrong Candidates
  • Conditions like diffuse unpatterned alopecia (DUPA), frontal fibrosing alopecia (FFA), or alopecia areata are usually not suitable.
  • Medical management should be the priority; transplant should only be considered if disease is proven inactive and donor quality is adequate.

Failed Hair Transplant - Our Corrective Plans

Example 1 :

Position of the hairline was reasonable, but the density was too low. Also the hairline was too rigid and orderly to be natural.

How We Fix It

Randomly add on density in front of and amongst the existing hairs

Example 2 :

The new apex was too rounded. The transplanted hairs did not match the existing ones in angles and directions.

How We Fix It

Punch out the unwanted transplanted hairs and recycled, will leave scars

Example 3 :

Not enough grafts to fill in the center behind the hairline, creating the look of a Kappa

How We Fix It

Simply add on the density

Example 4 :

There was inadequate density of grafts behind the narrow hairline.

How We Fix It

Add more grafts in the empty area.

Example 5 :

Asymmetry in the hairline – the right side is higher than the left by 2cm.

How We Fix It

Lower the right side by 1cm may improve.

Example 6 :

Difficult to style the hair as the grafts were inserted perpendicularly. Correct angle should be 35-45°.

How We Fix It

No!

Example 7 :

The typical ‘Corn Rows” appearance, when minigrafts instead of follicular units were used. The insertion was too orderly.

How We Fix It

Put some 1-hair FU in front, and add more grafts in between.

Example 8 :

Another typical example of the “Corn Rows” appearance. The pattern is more obvious on cutting short the hair.

How We Fix It

Add grafts in between inorderly to be more natural looking.

Failed Hair Transplant Repair - 8 Considerations

1. Objectives

  • To restore a natural appearance, improve density, and correct unnatural design or visible scarring caused by previous hair transplant procedures.
  • The goal is to optimize remaining donor supply while minimizing further trauma.
  • Repair must be realistic and prioritize visible areas.

2. Number of Grafts

Tell us the shape and pattern you desire, or our beauty consultant Sara is delighted to help. Sara is a certified beautician with years of experience. She will design eyebrows to best match your facial features. Or you can consult your own beautician. 

You can then ask your friends and family for comment till you are fully satisfied with the new look.

3. Number of Grafts

  • Typically 1,200 to 2,400 grafts ( 2,400 – 3,600+ Hairs ) depending on:
    • Size and location of the area needing correction

    • Type of deformity (hairline, scar, plug)

    • Most importantly, availability of usable donor hair

  • We avoid using excessive grafts to deplete further the donor areas; long-term planning is extremely important.

4. Number of Sessions

  • Usually 1 to 2 sessions:
  • First session focuses on major corrections
  • Second session may refine density or symmetry

5. Selected Areas

  • Frontal hairline redesign
  • Central density enhancement
  • Camouflage of old punch grafts or wide scars
  • Temporal triangle or crown refinement if donor allows

6. The Limiting Factor - Donor Depletion

  • The most critical limitation in repair cases is limited donor hair.
  • Every graft must be carefully planned and placed.
  • In many failed transplants, poor harvesting techniques or overharvesting have already depleted this resource.
  • Patients must be counseled accordingly, and expectations should be aligned with realistic possibilities.

7. Techniques Used

  • Chosen based on previous surgical technique and current donor quality:
  • FUE for precise extraction, lower trauma, and scar camouflage
  • FUT may be used when scalp laxity allows and more grafts are needed
  • Combination of FUE + FUT may be considered in select cases to maximize yield
  •  

8. Adjuvant Therapy

  • Long-term medication not needed for transplanted grafts
  • Oral/topical treatments like minoxidil or finasteride recommended to preserve existing native hair
  • Scalp micropigmentation (SMP) can be used to visually enhance areas with limited donor coverage
  • Hair transplant result should be preserved by ongoing maintenance therapy where appropriate
36

conditions of use

Medical Disclaimer

Information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. It should not be interpreted as promotional material or as claims of superiority over other techniques or providers.

Individual results may vary, and no outcome can be guaranteed. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional before making any decisions about medical treatment.

Pre-Consultation Review

Ensure You're a Good Candidate for hair transplant

Why pay for a consultation if you’re not a candidate? Start with our free WhatsApp assessment — the first step in our ‘No-Regret’ protocol to see if hair transplant is a realistic solution for your hair loss.

Still Have Questions ?

If you want to get a personalized answer from our medical team, you can reach us using this form here. We will cantact you as soon as possible.

Our Quality & Safety Standards

Our practice adheres to guidelines established by leading international organizations in Hair Restoration.

ISHRS

International Society of Hair Restoration Surgery is the leading global medical association that establishes international practice standards and patient safety protocols.

ABHRS

The American Board of Hair restoration Surgery represents the highest standard. To maintain rigorous certification requirements the physician must demonstrate surgical expertise.

WFI

Worls FUE InstituteI serves as the premier educational body focused exclusively on Follicular Unit Extraction methodology. The institute ensures consistent application of safe FUE.

This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.